My Wife Is Going to Alienate Our Friends With Her Ridiculous Wedding Gift Philosophy

Pay Dirt is Slate’s money advice column. Have a question? Send it to Kristin and Ilyce here. (It’s anonymous!)

Dear Pay Dirt,

Several of our friends have kids getting married in the next year. My wife and I disagree on how to approach the wedding gifts. I think her approach is wrong!

We are invited to all of the weddings, except for one, which will be a small destination wedding with no friends of the parents invited. I think we should give all of the couples the same gift, a check for a few hundred dollars (we haven’t decided yet on how much, but I think probably $200). My wife thinks that we don’t need to give a gift to the couple who is having the small destination wedding, since we aren’t invited. But I don’t think that matters; we aren’t being “snubbed,” they’re just choosing as a couple to have a different kind of wedding. I care about these friends and their kids as much as any of the other ones, and I think it is the right thing to do to give them the same gift. My wife really thinks this isn’t right and that giving them the same gift without attending the wedding is rude, somehow, to us. I understand her feelings are hurt, but it is important to me to be equitable here. How can I convince her that my plan is best?

—Wedding Gift Issue

Dear Wedding Gift,

It sounds like this isn’t really about the wedding gift but about the fact that your wife feels hurt that she wasn’t invited to this destination wedding. If you want to convince her that your plan is best, you’ll do well to address that first and foremost.

But etiquette-wise, you’re right. It’s not like the other couple is snubbing you. They’re just having a smaller wedding and prioritizing what’s right for them. Wedding gifts can feel transactional sometimes, but like you said, you care about these people, and that’s why we give people gifts, isn’t it? It makes sense to me, but if the real issue is that your wife is upset, it’s probably not a good idea to keep leading with this.

So start with her feelings instead. Approach the conversation with something like, “I understand why you would feel off about this. I’d still like to give a gift that’s more reflective of our relationship with them than their wedding choices, though. Can we find something we both feel good about?”

Once she feels understood, there’s a good chance your wife will be more open to the idea of being generous. If not, maybe there are some compromises you can suggest, like sending a gift card instead, or gifting the destination couple a slightly smaller amount. No one loves compromising, but if the two of you are truly at a standstill, it may be the only way to honor your desire to be generous while still respecting the fact that your wife feels a little salty about being snubbed.

—Kristin

More Money Advice From Slate

My spouse and I both work well-paid full-time desk jobs. We are both naturally savers, and have lived under our income for two decades while minimizing lifestyle inflation. We make 10 times the median household income of our city, but we are not generally flashy spenders. I drive a 17-year-old car and shop at local thrift stores. Our friends probably suspect we are well-off, but they don’t know the details. We are fortunate to have a significant amount of disposable income monthly and would like to spend it on travel and entertainment. We can easily afford to bring our children’s friends, or our adult family friends, along on our monthly mini-vacations. Examples would be a weekend at the local amusement park with platinum-level passes, or a short stay in a pricy tourist town a few hours away. It’s more fun for our kids to have friends there, and we prefer to have other adults along, too. I truly want to have our friends enjoy these experiences alongside us. But I know the other families cannot afford to reciprocate in kind. I don’t want or expect them to! How can I invite them in a way that would encourage them to come along without creating an awkward imbalance in our friendships?